ORANGE COUNTY, Fla. — Nov. 14, 2026. The Orange County School Board approved the district’s plan for employee compensation and health insurance Friday night, Nov. 13, rejecting a special magistrate’s compromise that the teachers’ union and the support-staff union had accepted, according to local news reports. The board was divided on the decision.
What the board approved
The board acted after about nine hours of testimony and discussion at its impasse hearing, ClickOrlando reported. The approved package includes a 2.65% performance-based raise for Highly Effective instructional employees and 1.98% for Effective employees, a 2.5% base increase for members of the Orange Education Support Professionals Association (OESPA), and a $4,000 base increase plus a $4,000 one-time supplement for eligible speech-language pathologists. The district says the compensation package totals about $56.6 million including benefits.
On health insurance, the four current plans become two: SureFit, which keeps a $0-premium employee-only option, and OA Plus, which replaces Plans A, B and C. The district says 81% of employees would see no paycheck impact or a premium decrease if they opt down, while SureFit premiums could rise by $1,056 a year for plans covering dependents.
Why the district rejected the compromise
Special magistrate James Mastriani had recommended raises of 2.5% for Effective and 3.5% for Highly Effective teachers, along with lower deductibles and capped premium increases. The district estimated those recommendations would add $105.1 million in costs and said it faces budget pressure, declining enrollment and rising health care costs.
The unions’ response
Union leaders argued that higher premiums would amount to a pay cut that outweighs the raises. Orange County Classroom Teachers Association president Clinton McCracken said he was disappointed in the decision, according to reports.
This story reflects news reports of the Nov. 13 hearing. The district has posted bargaining materials on its official bargaining updates website. Details of the approved plans may be updated.
Sources:
- ClickOrlando: Live blog, Orange County Public Schools impasse hearing (Nov. 13, 2026)
- Orlando Sentinel via Yahoo News: Orange school board approves health insurance hikes, angering teachers
- Central Florida Public Media: OCPS delays health insurance decision amid legal threats from unions (Oct. 22, 2026)



